Review: ‘The Only Living Pickpocket In New York’

John Turturro Delivers A Career-Best Performance As A Gentleman Thief In The Digital Age

New York has been the heart of many a film, from romances to gangster movies to comedies, and native son John Turturro has been in a lot of them. I would say no actor working today exemplifies the changing shape of the city better than Turturro, and that is more clear than ever in Noah Segan’s exceptional crime drama, The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, a charming thriller that serves as a farewell to the gentleman thieves of a bygone era.

There are so many movies out there about the impact of technology and AI on our future, but nobody has explored it from the perspective seen in The Only Living Pickpocket in New York. Turturro plays Harry Lehman, an old school pickpocket in a digital world. The days of cuffing someone’s wallet on the subway train for cash, or fencing a backpack of stolen goods at the local pawn shop, are over in favor of easily canceled credit cards and cryptocurrency. When we meet Harry, he’s just ripped off a fancy-looking guy in a suit, only to be told by his fence, Ben (Steve Buscemi), that most of the stuff is junk. The guy had no cash in his wallet, either.  Harry and Ben are running out of time. They are relics of an era that no longer exists. The world today doesn’t need hard cash, people don’t wear expensive watches and jewelry as much, and they don’t fetch as much money. It’s hard out there for an honest criminal, these days!

And for the most part, Harry is an honest guy, or as honest as a thief can be. He seems like a pretty good dude. Harry scrapes by through petty crime, using the money to care for his wife, Rosie (Karina Arroyave), who lies in a vegatative state for unknown reasons. He has a daughter, Kelly (Tatiana Maslany), who he no longer sees due to his criminal past. But Harry isn’t violent. He comes and goes without making any waves…until he steals from the wrong person. That would be Dylan (Will Price), a mobbed up kid who Harry steals from one night. He finds a duffle bag with a gun, a huge billfold of cash, a luxury watch, and a USB.  When Dylan finds out, he rages through the city looking for Harry, and when he finds him, he threatens to kill Rosie if he doesn’t get his stuff back.

I was stunned by the suddenly elevated stakes. While Dylan threatens to kill Rosie if he doesn’t get his USB back by 4pm that day, he outright tells Harry that there’s no hope for him, regardless of the situation. We go through The Only Living Pickpocket in New York knowing that Harry won’t be among the living for long; his mission isn’t about preserving his own life but in saving others.  As Harry travels the subways and trains of the Big Apple, he’s afforded the opportunity to take stock of his life and wrap up loose ends. Tuturro has a couple of great scenes with Giancarlo Esposito, who plays a detective Harry has a long history with. These two phenomenally gifted actors of a certain age, both of them Spike Lee veterans, sound like two old friends just having a chit-chat about life, retirement, and the recklessness of the younger generation. I would’ve paid happily to just listen to these two talk about pretty much anything. Meanwhile, Dylan and his crew are seen wrecking shop everywhere they go, and obsessing over intangible things that Harry would never give a second thought to.

Another surprise to come out of this film was director Noah Segan, who I’ve only known through his many appearances in Rian Johnson’s movies. Johnson serves as a producer on The Only Living Pickpocket in New York, and it’s easy to see why. They both excel at presenting vivid, detailed worlds for their characters, no matter what the setting. Harry’s journey takes him through Chinatown, Queens, the Bronx, Brooklyn, it’s like an endearing travelogue of the city, each with a distinct personality. Even the somber dockside finale serves as a sweet tribute, one that you can adore through eyes soaked with tears.

Surrounding Turturro is an excellent ensemble that includes Esposito, Maslany, Buscemi, Aida Turturro, and even Jamie Lee Curtis. This is Turturro’s movie, through and through. It’s an understated performance, one in which he never shouts or screams or gets angry, even though Harry is in a situation where he probably should. Perhaps Turturro feels a kind of kinship with Harry. They are both men who are seeing time pass them by, the professions they have lived by are no longer the same, the values they hold are no longer the same. Like Harry, we may never see an actor the likes of John Turturro again. I hesitate to say that he’s unappreciated, because I don’t think that’s true. He’s an actor who makes literally every movie better, and has rarely been afforded chances at the spotlight. The Only Living Pickpocket in New York is one of Turturro’s quietest performances, but it’s also one of his finest, and it should not be missed.

The Only Living Pickpocket in New York opens on October 30th.