Review: ‘The Mosquito Bowl’

War And Football Collide In Peter Berg's Powerful WWII Drama With Nicholas Galitzine And Bill Skarsgård

Clashes on the gridiron are frequently glorified using battlefield terminology. The easy reason is the violence and chaos in a theater of war in which one side is looking to physically dominate the other to claim its territory.  But there’s more to it than that. Other than combat, the key similarity is the brotherhood and camaraderie that intense struggle, overcoming the odds, and the sting of loss and defeat can bring. It’s what shines through most in Peter Berg’s The Mosquito Bowl, a WWII drama in which football and war intersect for a very special moment in history that has largely been overlooked.

Berg has found the perfect movie that combines many of his sensibilities. The Mosquito Bowl is based on the book by Berg’s cousin, Buzz Bissinger, who he collaborated with on the Texas football classic, Friday Night Lights. Following the attack on Pearl Harbor, some of the country’s top collegiate football stars set aside their dreams of football glory to enlist in the nation’s defense. Nicholas Galitzine stars as Brown University standout John McLaughry, with Bill Skarsgård as Bob Bauman, Ray Nicholson as Tony Butkovich, and Tom Francis as David Schreiner. Berg’s screenplay, written with Mark L. Smith, takes its time introducing each of the key players, giving them a distinct personality that stands out even when the bullets are flying.

Galitzin’s McLaughry carries most of the emotional weight. A born leader, he’s the kind of man that others rally around when the chips are down. Butkovich is the boldest of them all; the Purdue Boilermaker has a personality as big as the hits he shrugged off on his way to a rushing title. Bauman and Schreiner couldn’t be more different, but they’re buddies from Wisconsin University. There’s professional jealousy between Schreiner and Butkovich that they’ll have to set aside if they’re going to survive boot camp in South Carolina and the Normandy-esque bloodshed of the front lines in Okinawa.

Don’t let the title fool you. The Mosquito Bowl is more of a war movie than it is a football movie. After an hour of intense fighting, we get Berg’s smashmouth vision of the real-life Christmas Eve 1944 Mosquito Bowl game, played between two teams comprised of soldiers and collegiate standouts. While I could’ve used a bit more time spent on the titular exhibition, the grisly fighting is so intense that the game is like a breath of fresh air, as it likely was for the men themselves. It was a chance for them to be reminded of the lives they left behind, but also what might be again if they endure the conflict just a little bit longer.

Berg shoots both forms of combat with the same “no bullshit” style, with DP Jacques Jouffret tossing you right into the worst of it. War is ugly and grisly, with bodies being torn apart like something out of a horror movie, but the muted color palette used to reflect it is a drag. The physical toll is also taxing on the gridiron, as the soldiers are hit with the velocity of a freight train and sent hurtling through the air. Football was a very different game back then; less pads, more impact, more danger. Berg doesn’t shy away from any of it, but also shows how the brutality on the field doesn’t produce the same body count as war. At least in football, you almost always hop right back up after a big hit.

In that sense, Berg has delivered a surprisingly powerful antiwar movie with The Mosquito Bowl. I think he’s gotten a rap for being pro-military thanks to Battleship and Lone Survivor, and I think that’s true. But being pro-military does not mean pro-war, with the film focusing on the true costs of it on our best and brightest. It’s not the men who declare war who end up fighting it, it’s our young men and women at the peak of their lives, with dreams of the future ahead of them. How much have we set ourselves back by sacrificing them to the grind of war? In The Mosquito Bowl, the price is too high to keep mortgaging our future with the lives of our dreamers and our leaders.

The Mosquito Bowl opens in theaters on October 30th, before moving to Netflix on November 25th.