Review: ‘The Hunger Games: Sunrise On The Reaping’

Game Over Can't Come Fast Enough For This Tired Old Franchise

Remember way back in 2012, when The Hunger Game, and YA thrillers in general, were Hollywood’s fresh new toy? Well, “fresh” if you hadn’t seen Battle Royale or The Running Man or any similar film where games of death are in order. To be fair, the adaptations of Suzanne Collins’ books, which helped turn Jennifer Lawrence into a superstar, were quite good and even timely considering our fascination with reality TV. Watching children die for our entertainment is like the ultimate corruption of that genre, and a reminder of how cruel figures in power could use it for propaganda. But it’s been fourteen years, the original franchise concluded years ago, and it’s felt like labored efforts to just keep the money tap flowing. Following the utterly forgettable Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, which introduced us to a young Coriolanus Snow, the series continues with Sunrise On the Reaping, which gives us the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy that nobody asked for.

Set twentyfour years before The Hunger Games during what’s known as the Second Quarter Quell, Sunrise On the Reaping stars Joseph Zada as a young Haymitch. Woody Harrelson originally played the drunken, adult version of the character, who struggled with the memories of what he had to do to win. It’s Haymitch’s intense survivor’s guilt that colored his cynical approach to mentoring the rebellious Katniss, but this prequel attempts to wash all of that clean, putting the blame for everything that happened to him entirely on Snow and the ruling authority in Panem, not because of choices he made.

If they wanted to make Haymitch as uninteresting as possible, this was the way to do it. It’s the “Wolverine Paradox”; the mystery is part of the character’s cool factor, so what happens when you reveal too much of it? Nobody needed to see this chapter in Haymitch’s story. It was more than enough to see what it had done to him, and how it also made him the perfect guide for Katniss in her bid to overthrow Snow. Sunrise On the Reaping is one an increasing number of prequels/spinoffs that does the originals no favor.

The story picks up on the day of The Reaping, which coincides with Haymitch’s sixteenth birthday. Thrash actress Whitney Peak plays his girlfriend, Lenore Dove Baird, who quietly sings songs of rebellion against the Capitol. As District 12 residents, they are the poorest and least likely to win the Games; they’re actually like the annual butt of the joke. That makes it especially rough when Haymitch, just trying to be a good guy and everything, is forced to replace another tribute who died trying to flee. He’s quickly rushed to the Capitol alongside the other unfortunate kiddos: prickly twin Maysilee Donner, played by McKenna Grace, weirdo oddsmake Wyatt Callow, played by Ben Wang, and cheeky neighbor girl Louella, played by Molly McCann.

The beats are totally familiar, like a poor man’s version of the better, earliest Hunge Games movies. Actually, everything feels like a lesser version of a story we already know. They breeze quickly through training, where they meet the violent Tributes who will be coming to kill them. They get a fashion makeover by Effie Trinket, played by Elle Fanning, introduce themselves to the adoring audience. Kieran Culkin is the only one seeming to have any fun as the toothy, grandstanding host Caesar Flickerman, capturing the Richard Dawson-esque energy of Stanley Tucci. Haymitch is told to act the “bad boy” role to make the audience and Gamesmakers love him, and they can help keep him alive. It’s a tool that Katniss used to her advantage, but Haymitch does nothing with it. The film sort of forgets about it, as it does so many other things. Like adding tension and drama. Even when Haymitch is recruited by Beetee, played by Kelvin Harrison Jr. (following the wondeful Jeffrey Wright), into a plot to sabotage the Games once and for all, there’s no suspense to any of it. We already know he’s going to fail. Where’s my shrug emoji?

When Haymitch and the others enter The Arena, even it is shockingly tame. Poison water, electrified butterflies, angry birds, and a lava flow are only mildly more interesting than the non-existent threat of the Tributes, who all amount to nothing. Haymitch skirts along without having to make any hard choices or do anything that would give his character any color whatsoever. None of the deaths, even those of key characters in Haymitch’s orbit, holds any significance whatsoever.  At over 2 1/2 hours in length, the Arena is a circus with no showstopping act, and director Francis Lawrence, who has shepherded these films nearly from the beginning, is too comfortable to shake things up visually.

Zada takes some getting used to as Haymitch. It’s tough to see how he could ever be the same man as Harrelson’s version, but Zada is handsome, charismatic, and shows an innocence that makes it difficult to watch the pain he endures. He’s joined by Jesse Plemons as cameraman Plutarch Heavensbee, ably filling a role played by the late great Philip Seymour Hoffman. Plutarch sees all and is clearly playing both sides, but he’s as much a slave to the machinery of the Capitol as anyone, making him one of the film’s most interesting figures.

The same can’t be said for Ralph Fiennes, who is comically unscary as the “middle-aged” version of President Snow, lacking the menace of Donald Sutherland or the youthful naivete of Tom Blyth.

It doesn’t help when some of the original cast, all bigger stars now than they were then, appear in the final act as a sort of epilogue. They serve as a reminder of how vital The Hunger Games used to be, and how Sunrise On the Reaping should be game over for this franchise once and for all.

The Hunger Games: Sunrise On the Reaping opens November 20th.