Review: ‘The Social Reckoning’

Aaron Sorkin Torches Facebook, Celebrates Journalism In Timely And Engaging Sequel

Aaron Sorkin has necessarily made a completely different kind of movie with The Social Reckoning, his follow-up to 2010’s The Social Network, which he wrote for David Fincher. Back then, Mark Zuckerberg was still such a cipher to many of us that taking a deep dive into this young, socially awkward tech genius with too much power was enlightening and fascinating, earning Jesse Eisenberg an Oscar nomination. Years later, Zuckerberg is a known commodity and so is the damage he’s done to the social fabric with Facebook, so Sorkin has pivoted to a compelling, if imperfect, investigative thriller about the dangers of social media.

Written by Sorkin and resembling an extended episode of his finger-wagging HBO series, The Newsroom (which I loved), The Social Reckoning is inspired by The Facebook Files, an investigative report by The Wall Street Journal that utilized information from whistleblower Frances Haugen. Sorkin’s interest is in the impact Facebook, eventually renamed Meta, has on the radicalization of its users. Sorkin has never been one to pull punches, and he’s definitely not going for subtlety this time around. The film begins with a prelude of a white woman on the side of the road berating the Black police officers who come to help, all so she can capture it on camera and show it to her fellow racists on the social media platform.

It turns out, this woman used to be a progressive stalwart before she was radicalized by Facebook. Haugen, played by Oscar winner Mikey Madison, was this woman’s friend, and as a data engineer at Facebook, she realizes that it’s them who changed her. The Bear star Jeremy Allen White plays Wall Street Journal reporter Jeff Horwitz, whose dogged ability to sniff out a story makes up for his lack of tech expertise. Sorkin’s punchy rat-a-tat-tat dialogue works like a charm as the brilliant but abrasive Haugen clashes with Horwitz, a luddite who doesn’t even have a social media account and relies on interns to do it for him.

Sorkin knows that we are already aware of the damage Facebook/Meta eventually does, so he mines suspense from revealing how complicit Zuckerberg and others in his Inner Circle were. Facebook wasn’t just a company that misunderstood its audience and made poor decisions; it created a system that intentionally rewards hate speech and drives users towards content that will fuel their rage. Zuckerberg is at the heart of every decision. At one point during a mock hearing, he shouts at former mentor Charlie, played by Bill Burr, that he’s no longer a kid fresh out of university. It’s true. Zuckerberg is cold, calculated, and focused solely on increasing engagement, thus increasing his wealth and power. He hides it by claiming to be a “free speech absolutist”, but he’s really just allowing the worst of people to fester and grow. He sits back and watches as radicalization and harassment become Facebook’s primary form of engagement, creating a culture of disinformation that would lead to real-world consequences during COVID-19 and, of course, January 6th.

There’s no doubt where Sorkin stands in all of this. Much like his series The Newsroom, Sorkin is passing judgment and makes no bones about it. The Social Reckoning is sure to be a film that pleases progressives who despise Zuckerberg, Elon Musk, and other tech oligarchs who have cozied up to the Trump White House and made the world a tangibly worse place to live. Jeremy Strong’s version of Zuckerberg is even more robotic than Eisenberg’s. Zuckerberg isn’t the core of this story; he’s like an avatar for all of our worst fears of a CEO run amok, no longer caring what happens to the rest of the world as long as he’s proven right, made richer, and people do as he says. This version of Zuckerberg would be great pals with Tom Cruise’s Digger Rockwell from the recent flop, Digger.

Taking on the shape of a journalistic thriller, The Social Reckoning finds Haugen and Horwitz digging through files, rifling through papers, checking facts, making phone calls. It’s not the most interesting thing in the world to watch, and nobody would ever say Sorkin is as dynamic a filmmaker as Fincher. While the film drags in certain moments, it’s also here that Sorkin acknowledges the role that journalists have to play in staying true to the truth. Horwitz doesn’t know anything about algorithms, but he and Haugen managed to cause maximum pain to Facebook through tried-and-true journalistic techniques. Sorkin’s references to The Pentagon Papers and All the President’s Men kinda feel like he’s patting himself on the back, but they aren’t completely out of left field, either.

Madison, in her first major role since Anora, delivers another masterful performance as a morally complex character. It’s a more subdued role; Haugen is a bit shy but she can lord her intellect over those who aren’t on her level. She repeatedly says she believes in Facebook’s original mission: connecting people all around the world and allowing them to be their best selves. You can see her conviction shrinking along the way as more details about the harm Facebook is doing become indisputable.

White has the easier job. He’s basically our eyes and ears, a window into this complicated world most of us will never understand. His relationship with Haugen evolves playfully over time, until the two are trading quips like many of Sorkin’s best-written couples.

The Social Reckoning isn’t the artistic powerhouse of The Social Network, and it doesn’t feel like the gamechanger that will be discussed for years and years to come. However, it’s crucial commentary for the moment we are in right now. We should all be questioning whether our relationship with social media is healthy. We should all be pushing for journalists to hold men like Zuckerberg accountable. We should all want our elected officials to do something, anything, to rein in companies like Facebook, not get in bed with them. Sorkin has delivered a timely, relevant, and powerful call to arms. It’s on the rest of us to listen.

The Social Reckoning hits theaters on October 9th from Sony Pictures.