Review: ‘Klara And The Sun’

A Quirky Jenna Ortega Can't Save Taika Waititi's Oversentimental Sci-Fi Misfire

Taika Waititi hasn’t suddenly become a bad filmmaker, so what has happened with his last few movies? Following two straight duds in Thor: Love & Thunder and Next Goal Wins, Waititi returns with another quirky but well-intentioned failure, Klara and the Sun, based on the book by Never Let Me Go author Kazuo Ishiguro. Examining the inner lives of artifiical begins has been front of mind for Ishiguro, and I quite enjoyed Mark Romanek’s dark adaptation from 2010 because it at least knew what it was. The same can’t be said for Waititi’s overly whimsical, insubstantial, and surprisingly dull attempt at lite sci-fi, which manages to lack both humor and poignancy.

Jenna Ortega does her best to bring some color to a pretty flat affair. The beginning promises a lot of oddball fun, but the dark clouds descend quickly. The Wednesday star settles into another oddball role as Klara, an Artificial Friend in a future where robot companions are such a thing that there are competing retail outlets. Natasha Lyonne is a lot of fun as the salesperson who perhaps gets a long better with AFs than she does with real people in the outside world. She dutifully tries to find them companions in a world that no longer has the Internet following World War 3. The kind of world in which all of this has happened is curiously lacking in detail. The solar-powered Klara is weird, a bit of a dork, and totally lovable. It’s suggested she has a loose chip or something, to account for the strangeness approximating real feelings. She stands on one leg like a flamingo for no good reason at all, she’s just odd that way. Because she’s fueled by the sun, Klara considers it to be like a life-giving god, one she speaks to every day, creeping out the other robots. All Klara wants is for someone to choose her, and she gets her wish (she thinks because the sun granted it) when 14-year-old genius Josie (Mia Tharia) shows up, looking for a new friend. Amy Adams plays her uptight, overworked mom, Chrissie, while Waititi favorite Rachel House is the irritable housekeeper, Melania, who hates Klara on sight.

Taika’s quirk radar is completely out of wack, and has been for a while. The filmmaker who so expertly navigated the space between young adult comedy and adult drama, as with Hunt for the Wilderpeople and Jojo Rabbit, repeatedly mistakes eccentricities for insightfulness. Klara stumbles around her new home, in a strange wheatfield far away from the city, making a spectacle of herself until she realizes that Josie, who has been artificially “lifted” into a super genius, is terminally ill. Chrissie has already lost one child, been abandoned by her husband, and the hits just keep on coming. Chrissie has an ulterior motive for Klara that is telegraphed about ten miles away, and it doesn’t lighten the mood at all, no matter how many times Klara falls on her face or mistakes other machines for monsters.

While most of the performances are forgettable, including from the generally reliable Adams, Ortega’s natural charm and spirit go a long way in attempting to lift Klara and the Sun out of the gloom. Too much of the film is cutesy for the sake of being cutesy, with every development more contrived than the last, including a painfully misjudged scene where Josie meets other “lifted” kids and finds that they’re all a bunch of stuck-up bullies with bad taste in fashion. What exactly is the point? One brand of artificiality is preferable to another? It doesn’t really matter. There were five other people in the screening I attended today. By the time it was over, only me and one other had stuck it out. The others had the right idea, I think. Artificial or not, life is too short to waste time on such an arduous experience.

Klara and the Sun is in theaters now.