Review: ‘California Schemin”

James McAvoy Shows His Street Cred With Crowd-Pleasing Biopic On Scottish Hip-Hop Scammers

A Scottish boy who grew up to the sounds of hip-hop in the ’90s and early 2000s, it’s likely that James McAvoy has a soft spot for the unlikely rap duo of Silibil N’ Brains. The best friends from Dundee found that breaking into the rap game was tougher than they thought, and the London music scene was particularly harsh on a couple of Scottish white boys with thick accents. But this was the height of Eminem’s rise to fame, and everyone was looking for the next person to follow in his footsteps. So they pulled off an incredible hoax, posing as a couple of California kids and securing themselves a record deal. This incredible but true story is the basis for McAvoy’s charming, slight directorial debut, California Schemin’.

Samuel Bottomley and Seamus McLean Ross star as best buds Billy Boyd and Gavin Bain, who would become the faux rap duo Silibil N’ Brains. Before that, they were just a couple of struggling kids working a dead-end job at a call center. They have a dream of becoming rappers, but find that it’s basically them against the world. English prejudice against the Scots is a factor, but also their lack of street cred and goofy image. This is made clear in a horrific audition to be the next big signing to a record label run by the prickly Anthony Reid (played by McAvoy). Returning home more disillusioned than ever, the two hatch a scheme to deceive the entire industry into believing they are a couple of streetwise rappers from California. And once they’ve inked a deal and found success, they will reveal the truth and expose the biases within the industry.

So this deception begins with an altruistic, if ultimately misguided, goal in mind and it’s not just to become rich and famous. The thing is, they’re actually pretty good. They can spit bars off the top of the head, they have charisma and stage presence, and they come across as, ironically, real. “Keeping it real” was everything that mattered in rap at the time, and they had all of London convinced. Before you could say “D12”, the boys are superstars on the U.K. hip-hop scene, with all of the money, cool stuff, and women they can handle. Naturally, this blinds them to their original mission, and as for Billy, it also distracts him from his loyal girlfriend Mary (played by the wonderful Blue Jean actress Lucy Halliday) who has been their biggest champion from the start.

The rise-and-fall journey of Silibil N’ Brains is pretty standard, and the truth is there isn’t much to their story we haven’t seen. McAvoy, working from a script by Elaine Gracie and Archie Thompson based on Gavin’s autobiography, leans into the con game, giving the film an exciting heist thriller quality. As Gavin sinks deeper into the fantasy, literally blowing up at anyone who reminds him of his former life, the threat of exposure increases. When they start booking bigger gigs and meeting celebrities, the lies can only get more brazen, and thus easier to be exposed. At the same time, Billy is being pulled back into reality by Mary, which leads to a violent showdown between the two best friends. Dammit Yoko, why is it always a woman who gets in the way of a band’s success???

McAvoy’s strength as a first-time filmmaker is capturing the high-energy of live performance, the rush of adrenaline that comes from rockin’ a crowd that didn’t know what they were in for. The performances could’ve used a bit of guidance, though.  Ross is a live wire, but his performance as Gavin is emotionally scattered. At times sympathetically desperate, and other times borderline deranged, Gavin is tough to root for even as the dream he fought for slips away. Speaking of which, the film could’ve used a bit more time to breathe, showing us more of Billy and Gavin’s struggles, and allowing for us to soak in their successes. When the inevitable crash happens, that is brushed on by, as well for the sake of an easy, if satisfying, resolution.

Still, California Schemin’ is a lot like the rap duo at its core. No, it’s not pulling off some big con or anything like that, but it’s a scrappy little film attempting to punch above its weight and finding success at it. McAvoy’s direction is confident and energetic, blastin’ tracks from Golden Age hip-hop legends such as Souls of Mischief and Tha Pharcyde, groups that rose up from nothing based on their impressive skills. And that’s all Billy and Gavin wanted: to be recognized for what they could do, not judged because of where they were from. They might have been fraudsters, but their love of hip-hop was the real deal.

California Schemin’ opens in theaters October 9th.