Review: ‘Christmas At The Kringles’

Holiday Horror-Comedy With Ron Livingston And Rachel Bilson Is A Seasonal Misfire

Mixing horror, comedy, and holiday cheer is always tough, but Hollywood filmmaker have a long history of trying to pull it off. There have been some successes; for me, I’m partial to the recent Violent Night, the remake of Silent Night, Deadly Night, 1974’s Black Christmas, and of course, Gremlins. Kevin Lewis’ Christmas at the Kringles gives it another go, but misses wildly by being neither funny or particularly gruesome enough to appease anybody, which only makes its pessimistic attitude towards the Yuletide more frustrating.

Ron Living and Rachel Bilson star as Mark and Julie Severson, who have moved to a new suburban neighborhood with their son, Bobby, played by Jack Jewkes. They’re looking for a fresh start, but what they actually find are extremely annoying neighbors, the Christmas-obsessed Kringles, Nick and Carol, played by Thomas Lennon and Arden Myrin. The Kringles have three kids, and together they celebrate Christmas all year. It isn’t long before they’re shoving the holiday down the Severson’s throats, which Mark absolutely hates. But for some reason, Julie and Bobby find themselves drawn to it, which only makes Mark more suspicious. That said, a Christmas Eve dinner with the Kringles goes off without a hitch, so what can the real harm be?

A couple of months later, we find out.  Donald Faison plays Daryl, a lonely gamer dude who warns Mark that the Kringles are more than just weird, they’re dangerous. Rob Riggle plays a drunken mall Santa who knows even more, and is part of a group that intends to stop the psychos. With Mark too busy working to realize just how lonely Julie has been, he’s caught offguard when she and Bobby join the Kringles for dinner, only for him to be left out in the cold. It’s up to Mark and Daryl, minus Riggle’s vanished Santa, to infiltrate the Kringle home and mount a rescue.

Written by Zack Imbrogno, Christmas at the Kringles feels off right from the start, and like an attempt to ape better holiday horrors. The Seversons are pretty bland, which would work if the neighborhood was presented as weird and offbeat ala The ‘Burbs. Mark is utterly unlikeable, though, which has the dual effect of making us ask why she stays with him, and also explains why she so willingly befriends the obviously-psychotic Kringles. Most of the world the film takes place in is underwritten and illogical, from the strange cabal Riggle’s Santa belongs to, to the apparently nonexistent local police who never question what’s up at the oddball Kringles household.

All of this could be forgiven if the film were particularly humorous, but being jaded about the holiday simply isn’t enough. Faison, Riggle, Myrin, and even Bilson are light enough on their feet that it isn’t a total comic disaster, but I couldn’t get into Lennon who lacks the proper menace for his role. And for those hoping that a bit of gore will liven things up, they do finally get their wish but it comes too late to make a difference. Lewis, who directed the solidly vicious Nic Cage animatronic thriller Willy’s Wonderland, shows some deft use of editing to energize some of the action, but it’s like gold wrapping paper for a gift box full of coal.

Christmas at the Kringles is open in theaters now from Briarcliff Entertainment.